Why Buy Fabric When It’s Made Outside of the U.S., Too?

A few commenters brought up some great points in response to my last post. Choosing to make clothes rather than buy those made outside of the United States is all well and good, and it’s definitely cheaper than buying American-made, but what about fabric that was made outside of the U.S.?

The main difference between supporting foreign fabric production and supporting foreign garment production lies in the methods used. First, fabric manufacture, unlike garment manufacture, is highly mechanized with specialized equipment, and very few workers can produce a huge amount of fabric. So, simply because it employs less people, a fabric production facility outside of the United States has less opportunity to exploit workers. Second, because they are required to use complex, computer-guided machines, employees in fabric-production facilities need to be familiar with the operation of the equipment, which usually requires on the job training. In short, workers must be better trained, which usually means that a) employees make a higher wage, even in third-world countries, and b) employers, who often provide training to their new hires, are motivated to protect that investment by retaining their workers. They spend time and money training their employees, then must keep them satisfied enough that the those workers don’t leave and force the employer to spend more time and more money training another new hire. In addition, workers who are already trained and make the decision to move to another facility are more in demand and can thus expect higher pay.

Contrast this system with garment production, which uses a large number of relatively unskilled laborers who are fairly easily replaced. Owners and managers in this industry have little or no motivation to care for their workers’ health or job satisfaction, and often (usually?) don’t. When a garment production company outside of the United States needs to increase profits and/or lessen costs, the workers are often the first to feel the effects.

Now, all that said, I am not saying that fabric production conducted outside of the United States does not exploit its workers ever or at all. Foreign textile producers are not subject to the same workers’ rights laws and safety regulations to which American producers must conform. Workers can still be underpaid, work longer hours, and be exposed to toxic chemicals. Also, machinery itself can be very dangerous. And because the process of fabric production is so automized, hiring fewer workers is possible, but hiring fewer workers means less jobs are available over all.

Some also maintain that when we boycott non-U.S-made garments and the companies that sell them, we are actually hurting the depressed economies that often breed sweatshops. Sure, workers are paid pennies per pair of jeans, but if you don’t buy those jeans, you are, after all, depriving workers of those pennies. And by buying only fabric, we are supporting an industry that seeks to eliminate as many jobs as possible in order to manage costs. And it’s true that not buying a pair of Old Navy jeans keeps a few cents out of the pockets of sweatshop employees. However, the amount it keeps out of Old Navy’s coffers is much, much higher. We’re telling Old Navy to change the way it does business and we’re supporting companies that do business in a way that doesn’t build profits on the backs of exploited workers.

In the end, we really need to ask ourselves what we hope to achieve by boycotting non-American-made clothing. On a surface level, we are avoiding contributing personally to immoral business practices. On a slightly deeper level, we are trying to force companies to limit production to the U.S. because this is the best way to ensure that workers aren’t exploited somewhere in the process. Ultimately, though, it would be wonderful if Walmart, etc. paid even their international manufacturers a fair price for their garments. Then workers outside of the U.S. could benefit from plenty of jobs and better pay. It would also allow U.S. manufacturers to compete in an international market. This kind of thing, though, would mean higher prices in both our department and discount stores, at least until everyone got on board. However, we are willing to pay a little more to ensure that men, women, and children outside of the United States are not suffering so that we can save a few dollars or own ten pairs of jeans. And that is the real strength of this movement; we need to prove to ourselves and to large corporations that we are willing to change our American, sale-oriented mindset. In short, we must be willing to pay more for U.S.-made products. And we need to be willing to make what we cannot find or simply cannot afford.

As far as buying fabric made outside of the United States, it’s no question that there is likely some exploitation inherent in foreign fabric production as well as foreign garment production. However, the fabric production industry’s transgressions are not nearly as egregious or as commonplace as that of the garment industry. By buying fabric, ideally domestic but often necessarily foreign, we still ensure that we don’t support sweatshop-made clothing and we do this in a way that is personally achievable. If you live in an area where domestic clothing is available or find a reputable company that sells domestic clothing over the internet, and you have the funds to pay for it, by all means, please buy it. Support those companies (but do a little googling first to make sure those companies aren’t exploiting immigrants to the United States). However, if you don’t have access to these kind of items or don’t have the cash to cover their cost, you shouldn’t feel guilty about grabbing some fabric and spending a few hours crafting. Foreign fabric production does have the potential to exploit its employees, but you can feel confident that, because of the way fabric is made, you are not contributing to the sweatshop and child labor inherent in the garment industry.


10 Responses to “Why Buy Fabric When It’s Made Outside of the U.S., Too?”

  1. 1 Matthew June 5, 2010 at 8:58 am

    If you’re going to use a lot of denim, you can apparently buy it directly from a farmer’s coop right here in Texas


    Did you find any sources for American produced fabrics for people who wanted to go “all in”?

  2. 2 Jennifer S. June 5, 2010 at 10:39 am

    It’s a hard line to walk, I think. Being mindful of where your purchases come from, it’s everywhere! In coffee, food, clothing, shoes, toys, chocolate, everywhere! It can seem so overwhelming to try and wade through, so thank you for starting this conversation. Perhaps as a group we can do some research into labour friendly companies. It doesn’t mean needing to buy American made, but it does mean simply knowing the conditions of employees. I recently came across a small shoe manufacturing company called Ssekko. They make sandals in Africa and the women making the shoes are paid fair wages and work to earn their University tuition’s. If you’re in need of sandals, or a shoe lover, or even not, I recommend checking them out.

    • 3 everydaychaos June 5, 2010 at 10:33 pm

      Jennifer, thanks for the link! I will so check them out! Honestly, something I was really worried about was shoes, because I haven’t been able to find a single made-in-the-USA brand, and I know I can’t make them. If you know of any similar women’s co-ops, please let me know. I’d love to post some of them.

  3. 4 technology May 1, 2013 at 10:01 am

    If some one desires to be updated with newest technologies afterward he must be visit this web site and be up to date daily.

  4. 5 Judy June 15, 2013 at 9:48 pm

    The primary symptom of Achilles tendinitis and lipoma weight loss involve stretching and the
    pain of lipoma weight loss. The most important thing to look for is bio-mechanical alignment.
    Today there are more choices than ever in the styles of running shoes that is
    for your foot type. These should also be avoided. The important thing
    is to do this before you invest: Try to consciously hold your foot in both directions 10 times.

  5. 6 vertigotips.info June 27, 2013 at 2:43 pm

    There are three focused disease vertigo stretching exercises that can loosen the area around the heel: the towel stretch.
    You may do this sitting down, applying a fair amount of pressure
    and support to your heel gets overextended.

  6. 7 Mary McMullan April 30, 2015 at 11:15 am

    I just called Michael Miller’s customer service. I was told that their fabric is manufactured in CHINA and Korea.

    I am so disappointed that now top-name fabrics appear to be made outside the USA. And China to boot. Might as well go to Jo-Ann Fabrics.

  7. 8 towing service chicago June 16, 2016 at 9:10 pm

    Because diesel engines typically work beneath harsh conditions,
    putting quite a lot of stress on the motor, engine gaskets needs to be commonly checked.

  8. 9 dang ky 188bet December 21, 2016 at 5:40 am

    It’s fantastic that you are getting thoughts from this post as well as from our argument made here.

  1. 1 freedom mentor Trackback on February 27, 2015 at 12:51 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Chaos. Everyday.

Four kids. Two parents. Everyday life. Stop in often for new updates, crafts we've been working on, and a journal of life with four kids age five and under.

Photos of Our Everyday Chaos

Chaos by Topic:

Click here to receive email updates whenever there's a new post.

Join 23 other followers

Grab my Button!

Everyday Chaos Button

Copy and paste the following onto your page:

<a href="http://www.everydaychaos.wordpress.com" target="_blank"" target="_blank"><img src="https://everydaychaos.files.wordpress.com/2010/06/everydaychaosbutton.jpg" border="0" alt="Everyday Chaos Button" ></a>

Visit My Etsy Shop

Our Chaos Was . . .

oneprettything Photobucket

I participate in . . .

make it wear it
The Girl Creative

%d bloggers like this: